Exploration of Burnout, Emotional Thriving, and Emotional Recovery in an Academic Medical Center: a Mixed Methods Quality Improvement Project

Abstract

Authors:  Roxana Naderi, MD (1), Katherine Morrison, MD (2,3), Zuzanna Czernik, MD (1), James E. Carter, Jr., MD (4), Katherine N. Dickerman, NP (5), Alexandra Gallant, PA-C (1), Lara Kirkbride-Romeo, BS (6), Lauren McBeth, BA (1), Angela Keniston, MSPH (1) and Kristin M. Jensen, MD, MSc (2,7)

Download link for open access pdf

Introduction:  Healthcare provider burnout, an indicator of wellbeing, impacts patient safety, provider distress, and employee turnover. In this mixed methods, multi-site quality improvement study conducted <6 months prior to the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, we assessed employee wellbeing in a large clinical department.

Methods:  Wellbeing surveys were sent electronically to Department of Medicine clinicians, researchers, administrators, and staff from August-September 2019 assessing perceptions of Burnout, Emotional Thriving (ET), and Emotional Recovery (ER). Qualitative responses were reviewed for themes using mixed inductive-deductive analysis. The initial coding was done by small teams with consensus obtained through large group discussions. This study was IRB-approved as non-human subjects research.

Results:  Of the 671 respondents, 54% met criteria for burnout (Burnout+), 65% for ER (ER+), and 61% for ET (ET+). ER+ and ET+ were present in nearly half of Burnout+ respondents (53% and 43% respectively). Several themes emerged in the qualitative analysis: workload and expectations; tangible resources; work culture; and salary/benefits, with leadership influencing each of the domains.

Conclusion:  Burnout, ET, and ER can co-exist within the same individual. Employee wellbeing is not adequately reflected by the binary of whether or not an individual is experiencing burnout. All employees at academic medical centers, including staff, researchers, and clinicians, are vulnerable to the same workplace factors driving burnout. Our findings have been used to target areas of intervention during the COVID-19 pandemic at our institution. We propose that other academic medical centers may have similar workplace stressors that they could assess and target for improvement.

Affiliation:

  1. Division of Hospital Medicine
  2. Division of General Internal Medicine
  3. Division of General Internal Medicine, Section of Palliative Care
  4. Division of Cardiology
  5. Division of Gastroenterology
  6. Population Mental Health and Wellbeing Program, Colorado School of Public Health
  7. Division of General Academic Pediatrics, Department of Pediatrics, University of Colorado Anschutz Medical Campus